News | Published May 25 2019

Virgin Trains launch legal action against Transport Secretary

Sir Richard Branson has launched a legal challenge against Transport Secretary Chris Grayling's decision to bar Virigin Trains, and its partner Stagecoach, from the bidding process to acquire West Coast Rail. 

Branson has filed claims with the High Court calling for a judicial review of the procurement process, stating that the government did not adopt a competitive tendering approach.

The Department for Transport is already contesting legal challenges from Arriva and Stagecoach over the manner in which it tendered the East Midlands rail franchise. The government branded three of Stagecoach’s bids “non-compliant” back in April, amid a row over pensions.

The West Coast line is currently jointly operated by both Virgin Trains and Stagecoach with the proposed re-tender bringing on board the French state-controlled operator, SNCF.

“Stagecoach is an experienced bidder who knowingly submitted non-compliant bids on all competitions. In doing so they disqualified themselves”, said a DfT spokesperson.

“We have total confidence in our franchise competition process and robustly defend decisions that were taken fairly following a thorough and impartial evaluation process”.

The statement has faced backlash from both companies, as Stagecoach chief-executive Martin Griffiths said it is “disappointing” that the transport giant “had to resort to court action to find out the truth around the DfT’s decision-making process” over each bid.

Patrick McCall, Virgin Trains senior partner, described the situation as “frustrating”, claiming that the reason for the bid’s rejection had “nothing to do with looking after passengers or running a good train service”.

Authored by

Scott Challinor
Business Editor
May 25 2019

Featured Organisations

D 2 D

Data2Decisions provides consultancy on marketing effectiveness, employing a wide range of data, analytics and technology to provide concrete and tangi... Read more

Astex Pharmaceuticals

Having merged with a US-based firm in 2011, before being acquired by Otsuka Pharmaceutical, Astex Pharmaceuticals now have access to a global market. ... Read more

Rectory House Dental Practice

The provision of dental care, says Trevor Ratledge, is rapidly changing. Across the profession, and at Rectory House Dental Practice in Guildford, whe... Read more

Latest News